Size
Feeling lucky? The Mystery Hat is exactly that, a surprise.
The colour, style, and design are completely unknown, even to us.
The only things we do know:
Every Mystery Hat features the same signature magnetic closure found on all Ponyback hats, and it’s made with the same premium quality, craftsmanship, and fit as the rest of our collection.
No clues. No previews. Just top-tier quality and a little mystery.
✓ Cotton fabric
✓ Structured front
FAQ about the Mystery Hat
No. Mystery Hats are final sale and cannot be exchanged.
No. Mystery Hats are a complete surprise — even to us! The colour and style are randomly selected.
We don’t know! That’s part of the fun. Each Mystery Hat is randomly chosen.
Yes. You’ll be able to choose your hat size at checkout.
If you decide to return your entire order for a refund, the Mystery Hat must also be returned.
If the Mystery Hat is not returned, the refund will not be processed.
comfy & cool
casual vibes only
Nothing wrong with the hat it’s amazing. I ordered twice and received the same colour. Hopefully in the future you can try to avoid that.
Super cute color and style!
Very nicely made and fit is great--my go to hat on my European vacation!
Love love LOVE the colour, fit and functionality of this cap! Fits right and you can loop your hair through it regardless of where your ponytail is on your head.
Couldn't be happier with what was sent as my mystery hat. I purchased a black Adventure fit and my Mystery hat is a grey Everyday fit. Can't decide which one I love more.
j’adore j’ai reçu la marine
Sizing guideline was helpful and my hat fits perfect. The quality exceeded all expectations. I am obsessed. This hat is everything!
I was pleasantly surprised by the colour, I was a bit nervous ordering the mystery hat but ended up getting a cute baby pink one. Not my usual colour but that's what I need sometimes is a push to break out of my usually black and grey :) 10/10 I've always wanted one of these hats, I'm glad I finally did it!
Exactly as described. Felt a teensy bit tight hope it stretches with wear
Hat is too big. I have emailed to return hat, but have not heard anything back.
Love all my Ponyback hats, so I knew a mystery gift would be enjoyed, no matter what. Received a beautiful yellow sporty fit hat, will be perfect in the summer!
I’m rating 3 stars not because the product is not great I love my hat the system is genius but order twice during the mystery hat promotion and received the same in both order
This hat was white. There’s no variety. I know it was free…
Great colour! I was a bit nervous as it was a mystery item but I absolutely LOVE the gray. It's not a colour I would have ordered myself but I am glad it came as a mystery colour.
The colors of the mystery hat were so awesome. I'm very glad I got it because it's something I wouldn't have chosen for myself and turns out it was a perfect choice.
Great Canadian product! Innovative design that can be worn with or without a pony tail. Great quality. Will buy more!
Super happy with the mystery hat! I received the everyday fit in grey. Love it
Oh what a wonderful surprise! This hat is perfect! The size, the shape and the colour! I was hoping for pink or yellow and……..yellow it was! Thank you Stacie for making this incredible product!
I never would have picked this colour but love it! And the fit is perfect!
Loved the surprise freebie. Great colours and great quality.
Beautiful. The mystery hat was such a great pick. 💙 S/M fit is perfect.
It was a pleasure to receive this hat as a gift in my order. It fits great and looks fantastic — and I look like a dork in hats. I like the other one better but this is a good everyday choice.
I’m not a pink gal but it is pretty and I’m sure I can share it with someone who loves pink
The yellow colour wasn't for me.
I received the grey every day style, and so happy with it. Definitely a good fit!
Such a cute yellow!
Love the fit!! High pony, low pony or any where in-between. Messy bun? Yes!!!
Fits perfectly thanks to the sizing guide and so comfortable! Will definitely be purchasing again.
What a great offer. I got a tie dyed version and it’s awesome. Will be great for summer!
Beautiful yellow colour. Quality is always amazing.
Was very pleased with the color of my mystery hat.
Not the one for you?
